Roster cuts and Prospectus recap

Roster cuts and Prospectus recap

Posted by Bruce on Fri, 03/19/2010 - 12:18

We’ll get to our night with the folks from Baseball Prospectus in a minute, but first, the Cubs sent eight players to minor-league camp today, reducing the spring roster to 42. So much for the idea of Andrew Cashner breaking camp as a member of the Cubs bullpen. Cashner was among five nonroster men sent back to Fitch Park.

The others were right-handers Casey Coleman and Thomas Diamond, lefty J.R. Mathes and infielder Bryan LaHair. Optioned to Class AAA Iowa were relievers Jeff Stevens and Blake Parker and catcher Welington Castillo.

Reports today say the weather may affect today’s Cubs-Sox game in Glendale.

Last night, I had the pleasure of attending a book signing for the 2010 edition of Baseball Prospectus at the DePaul University bookstore downtown. BP’s Christina Kahrl and Kevin Goldstein hosted the event. Also on the panel was one of BP’s founders, Rany Jazayerli. The crew provided the Daily Herald with a nice introduction to a good studio audience.

Among the tidbits:

--The group feels that “we’re about one-fourth of where we want to be in measuring defense.” The BP folks cited John Dewan’s work in the area of defense as “groundbreaking.” The group, however, feels we’re a long way from being able to measure defense really well. They note that UZR (ultimate zone rating, which we cite here from time to time) is “based on incomplete and subjective data.” The good news is that “real data will be here soon,” and that in three years or so, most of today’s metrics will be obsolete.

--How’s this for irony. If you’re looking for the most stable labor situation in all of pro sports, look at baseball. Who’d have thunk that about 15 years ago? The last collective bargaining agreement got signed with barely a whimper. Football, basketball and hockey all have big labor issues staring them in the face.

--Kevin Goldstein is a big fan of Sox GM Kenny Williams. “Kenny gets a lot of crap, but I think he’s really good,” Kevin said. The BP folks feel the Sox’ starting pitching could be similar to what it was in 2005, and as I recall, that was a pretty good year on the South Side. We’ll see about the offense, but in the AL Central, anybody could emerge.

--The concept of worldwide draft was discussed. The Baseball Prospectus crew cited several potential logistical nightmares with such a draft, particularly in areas of the world not covered by all teams. Goldstein noted the Cubs have done an outstanding job of late in Asia. The problem with the draft, as pointed out by an audience member, is that players from places like the Dominican Republic, Asia and Venezuela enjoy a free-market situation while players in the U.S., Canada and Puerto Rico are restricted by the draft. The BP crew pointed out how the talent pipeline from Puerto Rico has dried up, and they linked this, at least in part, to the draft. What’s going to happen someday when a U.S. kid and his parents challenge the legality of the draft? Although the draft has been collectively bargained by the owners and the players association, high school and college kids are not part of either group. Somebody raised the question of how much the Nationals’ Stephen Strasburg would have gotten on the open market. Interesting to ponder.

All in all, a fun evening.

Bullpen/Rotation

Going by the schedule, the Cubs won't need a 5th starter until April 11th and then again on the 21st and Lilly might be back by then. I believe the Cubs will carry 6 relievers until the 11th and either Silva or Gorzelanny will be in the pen, unless Lou wants to carry 3 lefties (Grabow, Marshall, and Russell) in the pen, which I don't see. Guessing that Parisi gets returned to the Cardinals.

Judging by the way things are going this spring, here is how I think things are going to shake out. When Lilly is back, whoever is performing worst of Gorzelanny and Silva will probably go to the pen.

Zambrano
Dempster
Wells
Silva
Gorzelanny

Marshall
Grabow
Samardzija
Berg
Caridad
Marmol

Would not surprise me at all for Sean Marshall to be dealt for RH relief help and Russell and Grabow to be the lefties in the pen, with Gaub as a backup.

Posted by cubmadness on Fri, 03/19/2010 - 21:52
Draft/PR link

I'm sorry, what's the link between the MLB Draft and the Puerto Rican dryspell? It seems like it's more of a cyclical thing. If it's not a cyclical thing, why haven't we seen a dryspell of US born players?

Posted by Wish on Fri, 03/19/2010 - 13:41
Puerto Rico

Take a gander at this, which I dug up today:

http://mlb.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20070912&content_id=2204904&vkey...

It's really a mutifaceted situation in Puerto Rico, which back when this story was written had asked out of the draft.

Posted by Bruce on Fri, 03/19/2010 - 14:42
Interesting

If the draft has led to a lack of investment by MLB in PR and, it seems from reading that article, PR baseball players mean so much to the economy of the nation.....why doesn't the gov't just build the baseball academies?

I think of it this way, if the talent was there, MLB would do whatever it could to get it.

That's not to say it's fair that PR is the only country outside of the US that is in the draft. It's not. I think a world draft would work best so I can see where their argument is. I suppose MLB could/should provide some funding for those schools.

Posted by Wish on Fri, 03/19/2010 - 14:57
I'm all for...

everyone being a free agent. No draft!

Posted by Boozer on Fri, 03/19/2010 - 15:07
Me too

Let the free market work.

Posted by Bruce on Fri, 03/19/2010 - 15:23